User Data
I Agree
Our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy have changed. To continue use of this website, you must agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Let's review, shall we?

Let's review, shall we?

A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, and Characters. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a review is wishing to be disputed, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements or by another author.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
TheNerdyRat
witswithme
U_fido_U

4 slots taken, 16 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!
Add to Favorites
Pages
374
Updates
Monthly
Last Update
2 Weeks Ago
Fans
403
Readers
24

Accepting Author Applications

Must send in a Dummy Review to Yamataro or TheNerdyRat.
Read the FAQ or ask questions.
Must be able to deliver hard facts, not be Biased.
DO NOT APPLY IF LOOKING FOR A REVIEW. Just post a comment, saying you want a review. If not Taken care of, send a PM to Yama. Also, If you wish for Malakite to review your comic, you must ask him personally. He is only taking one comic at a time, and will do one a week.
Apply as a Co-Author

Let's review, shall we?

A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, and Characters. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a review is wishing to be disputed, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements or by another author.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
TheNerdyRat
witswithme
U_fido_U

4 slots taken, 16 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!

Recent Comments

nice review, ur still a cutiepie @Yamataro
Oh hey, it got reviewed. Thank you! That was some of the most constructive criticism and it is very inspiring to me. I really appreciate it and I will seek to improve. Hopefully if you guys are still around by the time I finish more comics I will submit more.
i'm glad u like smiffy's character development, i'm really going for an implied backstory in several comics instead of shoving it all in the readers face in one update. keeps it ambiguous.

i hoped that little teases of the past here and there make the characters backstories and personalities more interesting and relatability wise as this isn't a slice of life comic and the deeper lore should/will get deeper as to what this universe is like

i couldnt agree more w the random showing ups but yeah, its an author comic and people wanna be involved, thats why after ch 2 we had a rule where u should WAIT to be introduced to prevent deuce ex machina

along with that, id say a lot of the characters development is very mild as we have just begun, though a LOT of characters really havent developed much but will with their respective plots and such, but i do agree that w other characters, their weight isn't being pulled by the authors themselves.

plot 1/2 were messes, because we had nooby authors (that i should add turned out to be dicks), but we plan on making them important in the future regardless


thanks again for the review. based on your past author comic standpoints, i'm glad you enjoyed our comic
Sorry for the delay...
College is a pain in my ass but it's like that good pain when someone whips you and you are like- You know what, never mind.
College happened, review tomorrow. Sorry about all that.
wheres our review :(
This was only two months ago? Who keeps asking for this to be reviewed god damn
Very good review!
The comic can be found here: http://spacetravelisboring.smackjeeves.com

Also I apologize for the page bleeding out kind of large. Still getting used to making these on an Apple.
I'm rechecking on it, as the author that posted it is no longer apart of it.
Yamataro,

I'll complete this review in the next day or so. Have you checked on the review for the Sprite Comic "Explanation Unnecessary" or should that be removed from the list as well.
Well my list cleared up unexpectedly, due to author's not being authors anymore, so I need to find something else to review, meaning I might not post tomorrow, might post friday. Fido, floors yours if you want it.
Yamataro,

I can do Ian Evans's comic.
Sure can. Got another comic I gotta review before yours but after that, I'll be able to look at it, unless someone gets to it before me
Can a brotha get a review on a short and completed comic?

http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=169656
@Chunck.co: Don't ever be discouraged by what someone says. As long as what you do makes you happy, that's what matters in the long run. Reviews after all are just oppinions of someone from the outside, and as much as we try not to be biased, Reviewers always will have a little biased based on tastes and ideas. I'm glad to see you are willing to work on improving it and I'm sad I missed a few things you put out there. But for a 500 page comic, it's easy to miss things.

@Hero of Comedy: No kidding. It's like I'm basically the only one running this show. ...Wait, I kinda am. Ah well, it's my choice to do so that's all that matters.
You seem to be doing most of these since it was revived.
Thank you for doing so.

I understand it's not exactly great, but still thanks for looking at it.

I mean to be honest the sad part is despite nearly 500 comics i feel like i only begun.

It has a well thoughtout cast who other traits are to expanded but not yet. but a mismatch of plots planned at start and end without substance in middle. I mean i know this cause that how plots were made.

I am overthinking overplanning comic maker and this comic actually literally drained me but i know it's still not what it supposed to be. That is a slice life story about a large cast going through events with dynamic characters who gag sometimes. I mean i JUST showed the first antagonist.

Something i need to note is despite statement The characters have more dimensions Than implied and yeah i NEED to once update make every metaknight jr. Comment white text but it's hard to display characters and considering how i am it will take a while for their depth to actually be noticed. Each one's is more than prime traits but my pacing is horrendous cause i had to go slow cause the fast pace is bad for me. The characters are actually unbelievably over devolped in creation that due to how i am hard to see.

I go in detail to every expression compared to other comics by the way.

The arcs are...not at all well planned. especially at start. I mean i have a multitude of effects actually like motion blur's "effect text" but their not as seen except updated start and latter half.

But compared to original which got a -1
I call this a major improvement in score.

I mean overall it's more subjective outlook from a analysist asked so i aint as discouraged.

My jokes are very nonsensical i mean it not that i don't think of them it's more their depth is very easily missed.