Let's review, shall we?

A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, Characters, and Originality. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a comic gets a low score, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
D00D64
ElectroMan
Eluna Odis
girldirtbiker
u_fido_u
KonaTobennh
Whip The Rabbit
kmarwx
videojunk
witswithme

11 slots taken, 9 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!
Add to Favorites
Pages
362
Updates
On Hiatus
Last Update
1 Year Ago
Fans
401
Readers
84

Accepting Author Applications

Must send in a Dummy Review to Yamataro or Malakite.
Read the FAQ or ask questions.
Must be able to deliver hard facts, not be Biased.
DO NOT APPLY IF LOOKING FOR A REVIEW. Just post a comment, saying you want a review. If not Taken care of, send a PM to Yama. Also, If you wish for Malakite to review your comic, you must ask him personally. He is only taking one comic at a time, and will do one a week.
Apply as a Co-Author
A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, Characters, and Originality. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a comic gets a low score, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
D00D64
ElectroMan
Eluna Odis
girldirtbiker
u_fido_u
KonaTobennh
Whip The Rabbit
kmarwx
videojunk
witswithme

11 slots taken, 9 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!

Recent Comments

Hi, if possible, I would like to get a review for my comic, The Green-Eyed Sniper.

You can read it here: https://infectedbloodcomics.com/2016/02/01/part-1-page-1-2/

It's a sci-fi story with drama, action, secrets, love and dark humor. It's focused on lesbian characters. Flagged for language and violence, but generally SFW.

Thanks!
blueAleks
April 15th, 2016
World totally be down for a review if you're up for it. I'm always open to a good critiquing.

www.devilscomic.com :)
Hey got a solo comic going now, Path of A Raven, could I have a review when possible?

Here's the link: http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=155704
Hey there! :D When you get the chance, could you review my comic Sister Sister? http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=120511 It's a reboot of the original and it sort of just started, but I think there is enough to get a grip on the story and setting.

One thing I should mention is that I changed up how I did speech bubbles after a few pages in to chapter one. I didn't get the chance to re-do the old pages with the new bubbles yet...so that's why they may be inconsistent.

Thanks so much!

Note** It does have some blood and unsettling/creepy/scary imagery in it. Just thought I'd give you a heads up.
BIT.TRIP Comics
I was hoping you could review my BIT.TRIP comics. They are based on the award winning game franchise by Choice Provisions but given a slight twist with my interpretations of the characters with human appearances.

http://bit-trip.thecomicseries.com/
A Review for Fate or Imp?
Hello! I'm looking for reviews for my webcomics and someone recommended here first:

Fate is an all ages fantasy comic: http://fate.thecomicseries.com/

Imp is a 12+ interactive supernatural comic (the readers comment on how the comic will continue) http://impcomic.thecomicseries.com/

You don't have to do both and if you are only going to do one can it be Fate please?
Thank you!
Glad it was what you were looking for!
@Squirreltastic-Blue: Now as for what I meant, in at least one of your pages, you stated that you had trouble with certain effects. That's one of the things you have to learn more about. And as for the rest...comic-making is an always-educating job. Experimenting and figuring out what works for ya is a major part of the comiccing business. That's what I meant to say.
Thanks, Witswithme. I've been looking forward to this for weeks!

To clarify about Emperor Cream (the ice cream penguin), his felony was attacking people in the streets, and covering the city in ice cream.

If you are curious about the process of how the comic is made, you'd be correct that it is hand drawn and then digitally edited.

I'm curious about what you mean when you said I have a lot to learn, not from a egotistical "HEY I KNOW EVERYTHING" perspective, but rather seeking elaboration as I am curious about what any critic has to say. We learn from each other.
Clan
March 9th, 2016
@witswithme Thanks mate!


(Just wanna warn you though, its really crappy.)
witswithme
March 9th, 2016
@Clan: I'll look into the Mystery Dungeon comic for ya.
This took way longer than intended.
In any case, here's the link to the comic: http://nickpolarbear.smackjeeves.com/

Sorry Squirreltastic for the delay. The next review definitely won't take as long.
Clan
February 23rd, 2016
Eyy mate, I run two fairly crappy webcomics, and I was wondering if you could review one of them. I need to figure out how to improve, since I still have no idea what im really doing. If you could take a look at either one, that would be great.

The first is a Nuzlocke comic, thats really basic, but im trying to make it entertaining.

http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=158905

The other im trying to make a little more serious, and is a mystery dungeon inspired story about bio weapons and people and pokemon killing stuff.

http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=157731

If you could check either out, that would really be great.

Thanks for taking the time to read through this comment.
@witswithme: I'd prefer 3 and 4 be reviewed by someone with a close understanding of 1 and 2, but I won't say no to your offer.
@Squirreltastic-Blue: If you want, I could take a look at it.
@kmarwx: Would you be interested in reviewing issues 03, and 04 of Nick Polar Bear?
http://nickpolarbear.smackjeeves.com/chapters/85065/issue-03-the-viking/
Lol what is it with people and salty.
I wish I could elaborate more about this in better detail...
I apologize if the review looks confusing and disjointed. If you want me to explain anything I mentioned, I'll try to do so as best as I can.

In any case, here's the link to the comic: http://www.stefanotsai.com/Comics_Membrane/StefanoTsai_Comics_Membrane_Preview.htm
witswithme
December 21st, 2015
Eh, sure.
@STEFANO_TSAI: Why not?
I'll look at it.
STEFANO_TSAI
December 21st, 2015
Can you review my free comic: Membrane.
Hey :D

Just created one comic for fun with my spare time. That will be great if you can review it and give me some feedback. Any of them are all appreciated. Thanks a lot. Here is the link.
http://goo.gl/DmLBww
@BoltOfSpades: aim for the horn. I rest my case.