User Data
Let's review, shall we?

Let's review, shall we?

A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, and Characters. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a review is wishing to be disputed, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements or by another author.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
TheNerdyRat
witswithme
U_fido_U

4 slots taken, 16 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!
Add to Favorites
Pages
371
Updates
Randomly
Last Update
2 Weeks Ago
Fans
400
Readers
46

Accepting Author Applications

Must send in a Dummy Review to Yamataro or TheNerdyRat.
Read the FAQ or ask questions.
Must be able to deliver hard facts, not be Biased.
DO NOT APPLY IF LOOKING FOR A REVIEW. Just post a comment, saying you want a review. If not Taken care of, send a PM to Yama. Also, If you wish for Malakite to review your comic, you must ask him personally. He is only taking one comic at a time, and will do one a week.
Apply as a Co-Author

Let's review, shall we?

A multi-author reviewing comic. We review anything from sprite comics to drawn comics
to manga. We base our reviews on Presentation, Story, and Characters. We score comics on a rating of 1-10 and if a review is wishing to be disputed, it can be reviewed again based on Improvements or by another author.

Regarding Author Collabs, All authors must be willing to have their comics reviewed. We will not review a comic that doesn't have the OK from all authors.

Sign up to get
your comics reviewed today!

Founder: Yamataro
Comic Accepter: Yamataro
Reviewer of the Month: None currently

Our Staff:
TheNerdyRat
witswithme
U_fido_U

4 slots taken, 16 open positions for a total of 20 Author slots~ Sign up today, and tell someone you hate (or love) their webcomic!

Recent Comments

@u_fido_u

Understandable thanks for adding it still.
Btw the next upload for ktd is "drawn" but that's beside the point.
Thanks ^^
@Smiffy SMF <3
@Chunck.co

I added you both to the list. Sorry that I don't review sprite comics. I don't read the style, so I don't review them (don't want biases to get in the way).
Do you still do reviews...

I'm certainly not done updating 285 comics. if are could one of ya' review Kirby Tales in Dreamland?

http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=158987
may i get a review of http://explanationunnecessary.smackjeeves.com/
Thanks a ton! You got to this a lot quicker than I thought you would, lol.

"69 dudes" - Bill and Ted
:D I couldn't be happier with the score!

I'm definitely going to go over these suggestions and change what I can, thanks for letting me know about the instant turn-off. That's probably the biggest thing I can change right now. I'll probably end up re-drawing Chapter one and the prologue. :) About Crate being different in chapter 2, his personality does change somewhat, but I felt like due to setting it made sense since he's lived a sheltered life until chapter 2, I wanted a clear difference between him in an arena and in the outside world, hopefully this will make more sense later, but I can definitely see why that would have seemed a little weird. I just wanted to maybe give you an some reasoning behind a lot of weird choices I've made, haha. I really should make that transition better if I redo it though, you are totally right. Thanks so much for the review, I love having things to work on and you have given me a lot! :D I'd love to hear any other feedback you have at any time, thanks again! Maybe I'll see you around.
Reviewer Comment
Charming can be found at this link: https://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=160940

Author is artofjoe

On the side: Anyone know of any good alternatives to MS Paint on Mac? Definitely was a painful process developing the format for Smackjeeves without it.
@artofjoe

I'll review your comic Charming. Hoping to have it done in a couple days. I'll keep you posted!
@Yamotoro
Yes, that's fine. Anybody will do.
@u_fido_u: As of right now, I'm going back and looking at the last comments and posting reviews of those, from before we stopped posting. From there, I'm also taking in any new reviews that come in,so we've got a good mix. If you can find the old list, or wanna start setting up a new list, that's fine to do.

@artofjoe: Of course your comic is welcome to join the roster. I unfortunately can't review, but I'm sure one of my co-workers would love to look into it. If it's not up by the time I get back, I'll take it once the computer is up and running.
Hey, guys! I just found this comic, I think it's great that you guys are doing reviews for people. :) If there is room I'd love to hear what you have to say about my webcomic, "Charming." Be as harsh as you want, and I'll definitely take everything you say into consideration and try to improve. Thanks for creating a service like this, I can't wait to see what you have to say.
Good job Kevin! <3
Are we building a list of comics to review right now? It's seemed scarce every time I've checked the comments.
Yike.
Hope that settles faster than you expect it to.

Well, I'm almost finished with the KD Crew review, but stuff keeps getting in the way. So yeah. I'll get it out as soon as I can, then I'll see about what you were looking at.
So.. How are you guys?
Alright so let me explain why I've not updated this week. One, it's my comic, I'll update if I want to. Two, I've had a wedding for a friend that was way more important. Three, my harddrive decided it didn't like living anymore so my computer as of right now is... Well dead. Hopefully I'll have her running up by next week, but WCS, it might be the rest of the month. If that happens, I trust those that have decided to stay will review in my place, though I can't count on that, as they've got their lives. So for those waiting for reviews, cause I know you all are just *DYING* to get your reviews, *eyeroll* Suck it up Buttercup. We run this on our time when we feel like it. So yeah. Other authors, do what you can, I'm out for a week or so. Lata.
@Mushroom Flabs: Sure, I can give it a look.
I began a comic recently called the KD crew. I've been wondering if there's anything I could change or add to make it better, and I would love to hear some criticism

The comic:
http://www.smackjeeves.com/comicprofile.php?id=174076
Bans have been removed, as this comic goes up.
I'm going to say this once, if you are here to start beef with another user, take it elsewhere. I'm not here to stop beefs or start beefs, but I request that this comic space stay beef free. That being said, here's a review for an author that may or may not still be on the site. Woo, time to tell them it's up.
@Yamataro no it is serious, those guys were being jerks and they should apologize to you for it.
Sad to say that your comment is probably more sarcasm then anything, but even if it is i thank you for commenting at least in a somewhat respectablr fashion. Even if it is sarcastic.