Page 1 of 14

SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions (OVER!)

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 12:48 am
by tezzle
NOTE: Only post suggestions here. This thread is solely for the purpose of suggesting nominations, and nothing more.
Direct all questions/comments HERE. If you aren't going to make any nominations, please just don't post just to tell us that you're not going to nominate anyone.

Rules For Eligibility:
- Comics with less than 25 pages of non-cover/filler updates, or one complete chapter are not eligible for nomination.
- Comics that haven't updated in 3 months or more which have no official ending (in other words, DEAD comics or comics on extended hiatus) an are not eligible for nomination.
- The Committee will notify every author chosen for nomination in case we wish to decline nomination (Ninjies has already expressed her desire to deny any nominations she may be given). If we receive no reply before the end of May, the comic will still be up for nomination.

Rules For Suggesting Comics For Nominations:

- You reply here with your nomination suggestions, with a link to each comic or its profile page. You may suggest however many comics you want with however many categories you want.

Ex:
"I nominated [comic 1] [comic 2] and [comic 3] for [category]"
"I nominated [comic] for [category 1] [category 2] and [category 3]"
And any combination in between.

- If you see someone has already nominated a comic you were going to for the category you wish to see it in, nominate it again! The Committee needs to see how many agree with that suggestion. In the end, the suggestions are merely to help us see what the community feels about the comics, making our job in coming up with nominations that represent the whole SJ community easier.
- Obviously, you can't nominate your own comic.
- Comics that belong to Committee members are eligible. We have vowed to be completely impartial in our judgment of our own comics compared to others. If that's not enough for you, then simply suggest a different comic.
- The Committee will stop taking suggestions after March 31st.
- (The nomination categories are at the bottom of this post.)

Thank you and have a nice day.

- Tez

Nomination Categories:
- Best Comedy
- Best Drama
- Best Horror
-Best Romance
- Best Action
- Best Fantasy
- Best Sci-Fi
- Best Gag-a-Day (meaning best non-narrative comic where each page is its own individual joke)
- Best Sprite Comic (meaning best comic with edited sprites, sonic, megaman, etc.
- Best Original Pixel Comic (meaning, unlike the sprites, the art is completely original from the ground-up)
- Best Autobiographical Comic
- Best Underrated Comic (we are still in the process of determining what will constitute for an underrated comic. Most likely how much exposure it deserves based on quality put up against how many fans it has)
- Best Gaming Comic (meaning best comic about people who play video games. Seems specific, but there are a lot of them)
- Best Photographic Comic
- Best Stick Figure Comic
- Best Coloring
- Best B & W Comic (meaning best comic that is legitimately B&W by stylistic choice and not just because the artist is too lazy to color)
- Best Fan Comic
- Best Characters (meaning the comic with the best overall cast of characters)
- Most Improved Artwork (meaning how much the artist has improved since the comic's start to the present)
- Most Original Art Style
- Best Banner
- Best Custom Template
Joke Categories: (These are not meant to be mean spirited in any way. More playful ribbing.)
- Yaoiest Yaoi
- Best Sprite Recolor
- Longest Hiatus
- Best Fillers (meaning comics that are more filler than actual comic)
- The WTF Award (meaning most senslessly random comic)

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 12:53 am
by Neociz
Oh boy.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 1:25 am
by BreakerLOLZ
I nominate "Two Evil Scientists" for Best Sprite Comic.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 1:32 am
by SushiGummy
I nominate Wibble for Best Action, Best Gaming Comic, Best Fan Comic, and Most Improved Artwork.

I nominate Retro Farm for Best Comedy, Best Underrated Comic, Best Gaming Comic, Best Fan Comic, and Best Banner.

I nominate Pirate Cthulu Comics for Best Comedy, Best Gag-a-Day, Best Underrated Comic, and The WTF Award.

I nominate Orbit for Best Comedy, Best Gag-a-Day, and Best Characters.

I nominate Piss Mario for Best Sprite Comic and Longest Hiatus (definitely deserves this one).

I nominate Quite Nice Comics for Best Stick Figure Comic and Best Banner.

I nominate Purple: Red Blue Gold for Best Drama, Best Fan Comic, and Best Characters.

I nominate featuring Talking Guinea Pigs! for Best Comedy, Best Underrated Comic, and Most Original Art Style.

Edit:
I nominate Lunar Hill for Best Original Pixel Comic, Best Underrated Comic, and Best Characters.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 1:38 am
by Sho-Shonojo
I nominate Between Gears for Best Autobiographical Comic.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 1:45 am
by Momentosis
I'm not really up to date with the newer stuff so I can't contribute.

:(

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 1:45 am
by Shoku2121
I nominate Breaker's Sci-Fi Picture Theatre for Best Banner

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 2:08 am
by Guest
I nominate Comics I Made While Blindfolded for The WTF Award and Best Stick Figure Comic

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 2:32 am
by LegolianM
I nominate -

Orbit for Best Comedy and Best Gag-A-Day.

The Death Of Sydney Walls for Best Drama.

Dastardly Adventures of LAMP for Best Horror and Best Characters.

Beyond Temptation for Best Romance.

Shadow Sprinters for Best Action and Best Sci Fi.

Toilet Genie for Best Fantasy, Best Coloring, and Most Original Art Style.

Shyeah! for Best Gag-A-Day and Best Gaming Comic.

Uneventful for Best Autobiographical Comic and Best Stick Figure Comic.

Wedlocked for Best Underrated Comic.

Wolfen for Best B & W Comic.

Mokepon for Best Fan Comic.

Evil Plan for Best Characters and Most Improved Artwork.

Don't Fear The Reaper for Best Banner.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 4:22 am
by Dahliabot
I take back my nomination seeing as it's been on hiatus for 9monthes and probably has less than ten pages. Sorry Tezzle! ...Again, please don't kill me... D8

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 5:09 am
by Imi
I nominate Metal Breakdown for Best Action, Best Characters and Most Improved Artwork.

This is without a doubt the best comic I have read on SmackJeeves. I can't get enough of it.

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 5:45 am
by phoenixgem
I nominate A Girl on the Server for best gaming comic

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 5:54 am
by PerfectSephiroth
I nominate Detective Tarson for Best Comedy, Best Characters and The WTF Award.

I nominate Two Evil Scientists for Best Sprite Comic.

I nominate Sire for Best B&W Comic and Best Drama.

I nominate A Girl On The Server for Best Gaming Comic.

And finally, I nominate Shyeah! for Best Gag-a-Day.

Yay!

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 6:40 am
by Supertoad
I've got these nominations so far, and most definitely will be adding more in time. Would it be alright to edit my post to sneak in a few more noms? (mmmm, noms)

- Best Gag-a-day Schyeah
- Best Fantasy The People that Melt in the Rain
- Best Gaming Comic A girl on the server
- Best B & W Comic The Private Files of Fowl
- Best Fan Comic The Legend of Mushroom Kingdom
- Most Original Art Style Untitled

Re: SJ Awards '10 Nomination Suggestions

PostPosted: January 9th, 2010, 7:26 am
by cqclegoman
I nominate 'Breaker's Sci-Fi Picture Theatre' for best banner.